A claim here can be traced to a public listing read, to a third-party test that states its scale, to our own dated catalogue sample, or to nothing at all, in which case the page says not verified. The category to use is decided by what the source can support, not by what makes the sentence stronger. Where two categories could carry the same sentence, the weaker one is used and the page says why.
What are the four categories?
| Category | What it is | What it cannot tell you |
|---|---|---|
| Public listing reads | What is being offered, written how, at what asking price, on a given date. | Whether the description is true. A listing that names a cloned calibre has told you what it claims, not what is inside the watch. |
| Third-party comparison tests | A measurement somebody else made, with its method attached, on the references it covered. | Anything outside those references. A test is never averaged into a score of ours and never restated as a verdict. |
| First-party catalogue reads | Ranges, medians and sample sizes, each printed with the date of the read and the number of listings behind it. | Why one seller prices higher than another. It is an observation of asking prices, not of costs, and not of transactions. |
| Not verified | A precise statement of where this site stops. | Fill a gap. A missing answer here means the material was not there when it was read, not that something was found. |
1. What can a public listing tell you?
The pages a seller publishes: listing titles, product photographs, asking prices, and the shipping, returns and warranty wording on the page that carries them. Read with automated tools, kept as a dated snapshot, published without the seller being named.
What is being offered, written how, at what asking price, on a given date. It does not answer whether the description is true. A listing that names a cloned calibre has told you what it claims, not what is inside the watch.
Prices published from this category are ranges with a sample size and a date. They are statements about a market, and they stay true whether or not anyone is named beside them, so the seller is left out and the date is kept in.
2. What do third-party comparisons settle?
Comparisons run by an independent party that states its scale and its limits. They are reproduced with a link to the original and the caveats their authors attached, and they are named, because a test without an author cannot be checked.
One example is the 2026 Submariner comparison published on Replica Watch Info, which states its scale and what it could not cover. It appears on a factory profile and on the ranking guide with those limits beside it. A comparison that does not state its scale is not used here, however useful its conclusion looks.
Anything outside those references. A test is never averaged into a score of ours and never restated as a verdict.
3. What does our own catalogue measure?
The asking-price sample behind the spread figures on this site. Our own catalogue of public listing pages, collected on a schedule, keyed by reference number and factory label, and anonymised before publication: the category is published, the source domains are not.
The current sample is dated 2026-11-09. Every spread, median and quartile on this site is computed from it at build time, so a figure cannot drift away from the data behind it. The number of catalogues read and the number of listings behind a figure are printed next to it.
Why one seller prices higher than another. It is an observation of asking prices, not of costs, and not of transactions.
4. What does not verified mean?
The questions the public record does not answer: who owns a workshop, how much it produces, which steel grade a batch used, whether a label still exists. They are published as open questions, with the question stated.
Fill a gap. A missing answer here means the material was not there when it was read, not that something was found. An entry can be correct and still incomplete, and a page that lists four open questions is more useful than one that closes them with a plausible sentence.
What about pages that explain rather than measure?
Some pages explain how a part of the trade works rather than report a measurement: the first-order checklist, the QC-set guide, payment methods, shipping claims. They carry their own reasoning and link to the page where each figure lives, with that page's date.
Stand in as evidence. Where a number appears, it comes from one of the categories above and is linked with its date.
What will this page not do?
- Name a seller as the source of a price. The category is published; the domain behind a row is not.
- Score, rank or recommend a seller or a factory. Where a third party published a test, its numbers are reproduced with its caveats and its name.
- Link to a place where a watch can be bought. There is no such link anywhere on this site.
- Publish a figure without the date of the read and the size of the sample behind it.
How does right of reply work?
A business that finds a statement about itself here can reply through the complaints and corrections channel. The reply is published beside the statement it answers, at the same length and without editing, and the statement is re-checked against the source that carried it.
How are corrections and removal handled?
A correction starts with the page and the sentence. Where a source turns out to be wrong or superseded, the page is corrected and the change is noted rather than swapped in silently. Where a rights-holder asks for material to be removed, product-level material is removed: photographs and listing content go, while factory-level and terminology-level material stays, because it describes the state of the trade rather than one listing. Both routes are the same page, and the address is admin@repdb.io.
Checked on 2026-11-12. Each guide page prints the categories it relies on, with the date it was checked against each one. See also how entries are written and reviewed and about this site.